Greetings!

This page is intended to provide the reader an insight into the functionality of a perpetually whimsical mind.

Thursday, February 09, 2006

Danish Cartoons in Egyptian Newspaper



It has come to my attention that a blogger from Egypt came across a copy of Al-Fagr, which supposedly reprinted the original, Jyllands-Posten controversial cartoons of Muhammad a month after the original caricatures were published. As you can see here, he has been kind enough to take snapshots of the newspaper, and circled the dates for our convenience. He claims Egypt should be boycotted as well by Muslims because an Egyptian newspaper had done exactly what Western Newspapers have been doing. However, what he has failed to specify is WHY Al-Fagr had printed those cartoons. I seriously doubt this newspaper printed those cartoons to make a mockery of Islam and its most valued icon, Prophet Muhammad.

I do not care if there are newspapers covering this controversy and in the process, showing these images. What I am concerned about is why they were printed in the first place. There may be some, who are against the idea of reprinting them altogether, but I believe to illustrate a news piece, it is important to add some visual aide. This is exactly what Al-Fagr and other Western newspapers may have been trying to accomplish and to protest against that is not sensible to me. The fact that the Danish newspaper printed it in the first place is most bothersome and all opposition must be against that particular newspaper, and perhaps the government, but not the media that is helping getting the word out to the rest of the world. The German, French, Norwegian newspapers are printing those cartoons to show the world what this global commotion is about, which is exactly what this issue demands.

Mr. Sandmonkey would do us all a big favor if he translated the news caption and informed us whether the cartoons were printed with the intention of mocking the religion, or to inform other Muslims about the issue. If the latter is the case, and it adds fuel to the Muslim anger, then it is serving the correct purpose, because such irreverence should not be committed by anyone, and all Muslims should be informed about it so that a united stand can be taken against such acts. Of course, pursuing violent methods to get one's point across is futile and should not be sought at all, and it is something that has simply plunged the issue from moderate to critical. Let us hope that this controversy ends soon and we can all go back to living our lives and also hope that people can be sensible and rational enough not to anger other people when they know beforehand that the repercussions of their actions may result in contention.

5 comments:

Abbas Halai said...

intention of mocking the religion

i don't believe this was the danish intent either. cartoon's and comics never have an intention to mock anything. they are there serving a purpose that depicts far more than words can. if you've ever followed comic strips in your life such as anything from peanuts, to the phantom, to even batman or superman, or your regular newspaper comic strips like calvin and hobbes and zits and so on and so forth, you'd know what i'm talking about. more commentary available on my page.

it is only the muslim media hype that is convinced for extremist reasons that they are being mocked. it's a stupid response to an event that makes no sense in any terms whatsoever.

Abrar said...

So the saga continues!! I think this issue is realy getting out of hands and no possible solution seems avaialble.

Yesterday I saw a clipping from a Protest in Pakistan during the Aushora and the cleric said that the only solution to this issue is to bring the Danish Cartoonish to death!! This is just getting way out of hands and really showing ppl that we are indeed extrermists!!

Your comment is there and thanks for it. Lets see if DCS has any replies to it!! I think I am gonna do a follow-up on this soon!!

Regards

Asad Raza said...

Abbas, in the business of publication, there is a major difference between a comic strip intended to humor or entertain people, and satire. Satirical comics or publications are intended to "entertain" people through ridiculing or mocking the beliefts, ideologies or personalities of people.

This is without doubt, satire, and not everyone enjoys satire. I am not sure what your faith is, but for us Muslims, any irreverence towards religion is not taken lightly. By trying to tell us Muslims to calm down on this issue is inappropriate because no one has the right to ask us to amend our beliefs and principles to satisfy others. Besides, this was an unprompted, and open assault on Islam.

I admit that the violent reactions were not prudent, however, protesting and requesting an apology is not implausible.

Abbas Halai said...

why don't hindu's protest everytime we kill a cow for dinner?

Asad Raza said...

We're not the only one doing that. The entire world does it. Besides, Muslims aren't asking them to stop making cartoons completely, becuase that would be an irrational request. The protest is to not depict OUR prophet Muhammad as a terrorist! There is a HUGE difference between what you are asking and what this issue is about.